Friday, April 17, 2020
Legitimate Genres
My first thought when people come after a genre because it isn't a "legitimate" read is, "And your findings are based on your opinion, simmer down". It takes to much unnecessary effort to be so negative over something that doesn't affect you. I have gotten into debates with friends and colleagues about the merits of certain genres (Romance and Young Adult).
I will admit that I once thought of these genres as "trash reading" but over time, I have come to realize that this was because that is what I was taught to think. From elementary to even into college, it is implied that the only books worth reading are the classics or sophisticated literary fiction. Since working for a library, I have developed the mentality that the only qualification for a book worth your time is one that you want to read.
I think the first step to breaking the stigma towards any genre is to stop that train of thinking early on. Or even have debates with patrons on the subject but no allowing it to get any more heated than a friendly discussion. I use the argument that many people use reading an escape from their own reality and we all have different ideas of where we'd like to escape to.
All books are for everyone, regardless of age.
Another way to expose more people to genres like Young Adult and Graphic Novels is when creating Reader's Advisory Displays is to include these novels as well. For example, if the display is for memoirs, include Graphic Novel memoirs in the mix. Sometimes the way to introduce someone to a whole new genre is to present them with something very similar to what they already like to read.
There are bigger fish to fry, read what you want and let others do the same.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
You're right and you should say it! This is a little sneakier, but my library keeps a few duplicates of YA titles in the adult fiction section (with adult fiction labels and everything) because the titles were so popular that they "crossed over" among age groups. If a debate won't work, inter-filing some titles (especially in displays like you said) might help people try new things. This probably won't work as easily with graphic novels, but who knows! Great post!
ReplyDeleteGreat idea about incorporating more YA and graphic novels into a readers advisory displays. I am a sucker for a good display and have found several books that I would normally pick over had they not been in a display. It would also be a more discreet way for individuals who may feel embarrassed to pick out a YA or graphic novel to try out the genres without having to browse the sections.
ReplyDeleteI strongly agree that all books are for all people! There are both well-written and poorly written books at the juvenile fiction, YA and adult levels. I just finished reading Shine, a JF title, and absolutely loved it. But I have recently had to return several audio books written for adults because they were so horrible in the first couple hours (or in some cases, minutes) of listening, that I just couldn't go on! And some of my all-time favorite books are YAs.
ReplyDeleteIt has never occurred to me to check the graphic novel section when looking for books for a display, but I really need to do that, since they are covering more and more subjects, and are a very popular format.
I love your closing line! You bring up so many valid points. Great, impassioned post. Full points!
ReplyDelete